There is an argument to be made that the system is incentivized against studying off-patent drugs for newer applications. But I remember from my grad school days a neighbouring academic lab that was studying metformin, a common drug for diabetes approved in Canada in 1972, to see if it had other applications. And now ANYONE can do the same survey I did and prove it. It matters what a country does to control transmission inside the country, just as much as it matters controlling what comes in. Not sure if anybody has continued to track how long is the "maximum" amount of time . An article widely shared on social media claims more than 150,000 people have died from COVID-19 vaccines. In this article, I will explain the evidence and thinking behind all my claims. Massachusetts health officials on Sunday reported zero coronavirus deaths and 33 new virus cases, which is the Bay State's lowest ever single-day case count since last March at the start of t Kirsch's presentation said: "Pfizer vaccine kills more people than it saves.". Example video title will go here for this video. On the other hand, finding a country without excess deaths does prove the vaccine is safe if the vaccine is deadly, it has to be deadly everywhere. I tried summing up the excess deaths in the 3 months before vaccination started and the 3 months after it started. European countries had a CFR spike because every country in Europe had a covid spike during the winter. Fluvoxamine is a selective serotonin reuptake inhibitor (SSRI) that is used primarily to treat obsessive compulsive disorder in adults and children ages 8 and up. Neither Medium, SendGrid, nor Facebook returned requests for comment from MedPage Today. In another case, Steve offered to pay a doctor $10,000 to have a debate and then refused to pay out afterwards. Another possibility is that Crawford is just seeking status and belonging in a community. And they dont have to play by the rules. There has been at least one case report of acute fluvoxamine toxicity and death. This is extraordinary. A clinical trial has demonstrated that the likelihood of hospitalisation was significantly reduced for patients with mild COVID-19 when given fluvoxamine. Make a donation - COVID-19 Early Treatment Fund, For Web3 Collectors, Neal Stephensons 1-Of-1 NFT Is The Ultimate Metaverse Artifact With Bespoke Utility, Thinking Like A Magician Will Help You Imagine Branded Experiences, CMOs Reconsider Your Hybrid Communications Strategy, Rhuigi Villaseor Kept His Foot On The Gas. Among the 65 who took fluvoxamine, none were hospitalized, compared with six of 48 (12.5%) who declined the drug (P=0.005). I can tell you I have done nothing but lose money on this endeavor," he said in an interview. Fluvoxamine and the COVID Early Treatment Fund. Even the government admits that there is a 1 in a million risk that some covid vaccines can kill you from blood clotting. For Steves world saving drugs to be important, the covid vaccines have to be bad. Obviously, a new drugs patent can be very profitable when the drug is brought to market, and it can pay for that drugs research and development (as well as the R&D behind a number of other drugs that didnt pan out). Steve thinks otherwise. The Substack letter published on Dec. 28 by Steve Kirsch, an individual previously fact-checked by Reuters ( here and here ), calls for an immediate halt to vaccine rollouts, saying the. This is a very wide range; it accommodates people who have cardiac injury. I have been vaccinated and my entire family has beenvaccinated. More than 485 million doses of COVID-19 vaccines were administered in the United States from Dec. 14, 2020, through Dec. 13, 2021. Another anti-vaxxer (Igor Chudov) wrote to tell me that he likes getting followers and he likes making contributions. Steve said he wouldnt debate unless he could pick the judges, and he nominated 2 judges that already agreed with him. A clinical trial has demonstrated that the likelihood of hospitalisation 7 October 2020 | By Victoria Rees (European Pharmaceutical Review). So this number always depends on the numerator (covid deaths) and the denominator (covid cases). Before becoming a full-time telemedicine doctor, Haider worked as a hospitalist for about 10 years. People would be lining up to complain about their loved ones mysteriously dying. Excess deaths line up with covid deaths just about everywhere. On Jan 6, my first class medical was deferred, due to 2nd AV block, Mobitz type 2 (see picture of EKG with diagnosis). I think thats referring to drug overdoses. Robert Malone, Steve Kirsch & Bret Weinstein Discuss: Spike Protein From Vaccine Is Dangerous Posted By Ian Schwartz On Date June 22, 2021 Video unavailable This video is unavailable Watch on. For some reason, this reminds me of QAnon. I don't think the doctor signing the class 1 medical certificate has any say in whether you pass or not. It turns out this argument fails, too, because there are many countries that had no excess deaths, even when old people were getting the shots. The censorship isnt what held the drug back. In a 2008 blog post, Kirsch reminisced about urging people not to vote for Bush in 2000: He would be a disaster as President, Kirsch wrote, since he had a track record of ignoring facts, ignoring science, and twisting the facts to support his misguided beliefs., Take-home message: To have not just one person, but him and his wife? And now, his ego is wrapped up in the generic drugs project. There are two particular drugs you suggest should be used for early treatment ivermectin and fluvoxamine. But there is an ethical problem here, according to Steven Joffe, MD, MPH, chief of medical ethics at the University of Pennsylvania Perelman School of Medicine. More than a year after Covid-19 turned into a pandemic, there are few therapies that have proven to work. No booster. Steve Kirsch background. As far as his mouth is concerned, there were 150,000 vaccine deaths. The best way to test Steves claim is to look at the excess deaths to find all those unreported deaths. But as the public health crisis dragged on, Kirsch, whose credentials are in electrical engineering and computer science, started to become a misinformation superspreader, as MIT Tech Review reported. He wants to be recognized for it. My best guess right now is that over 50M Americans sustained some amount of heart damage from the shot. This can cause deafness, blindness, inability Some people call this the Ikea Effect of misinformation: people are more attached to things they put together themselves, so if you get them to follow along on an anti-vax data site and feed them breadcrumbs, theyll be more convinced that the vaccines are deadly. "Steve Kirsch reached out and said look at all this stuff on fluvoxamine," Haider said. Only 350,000 of these deaths were logged as covid deaths: Besides the covid deaths, we have 32,000 extra deaths from heart disease, 9,000 extra strokes, 12,000 deaths from Alzheimers, 14,000 from diabetes. What we can say with increasing confidence, he writes, is that it appears less and less likely that we will end up finding a benefit for the drug.. Steve never replied to Angelas offer. California had a covid problem that next winter while New York did better: So, heart disease deaths only spike in states that are currently having a wave of covid deaths. So, what caused those extra 32,000 heart disease deaths? Thus far, CETF has raised funding for clinical trials for drug candidates includingPeginterferon lambda, a hepatitis D treatment, and Camostat mesylate, a protease inhibitor used to treat reflux esophagitis and chronic pancreatitis. Opinions expressed by Forbes Contributors are their own. I did the research when I got Waldenstrms and, even with treatment, the mortality rate was about five years, he said. To stop screaming about 150,000 vaccine deaths. It should kill you in Hawaii as easily as in California. In the second case, you had to prove there were zero vaccine deaths. Psychologically, Steve has to throw all of his energy at the vaccines being bad. Days to death from Dec 15, 2020 in Medicare in Connecticut. As recently as this spring, Steve Kirsch and his COVID-19 Early Treatment Fund (CETF) were riding high. The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) told Reuters this claim is inaccurate and . The changes were made on October 24, 2022 to the GUIDE FOR AVIATION MEDICAL EXAMINERS. CFR goes up because testing numbers stay constant, but the true numbers of cases go up. During this time, VAERS received 10,483 reports of death ( 0.0022%) among people who received a COVID-19 vaccine. There is no confirmed evidence of a COVID-19 vaccine causing the death of even one child. The cleaner told him he had received Pfizers vaccine and had had a heart attack two minutes later. After providing a disclaimer, he appears to give medical advice in a post entitled "How I would Treat COVID." Has previously been in & out of hospice care, resided in nursing home for 9+ years, elderly with dementia. Get yourself a copy of. How did he know this? So, there have definitely been more than zero vaccine deaths. Its eye opening. One is to reduce the threat of nuclear war. We know theres a pandemic going on, because more people are dying than in a normal year. But, it would happen in a shorter period of time. The fact that the Thailand study was published in a peer-reviewed journal, that they only did the easy-to-do assessments (which only found a portion of the damage), and the FAA quietly changed their EKG guidance should at least open your mind to the possibility that I might be right. About three to five patients per day have acute COVID-19, most of whom are receiving fluvoxamine from him. On October 24, 2022, the FAA quietly, without any announcement at all, widened the EKG requirements necessary for pilots to be able to fly. The 23 countries hes pointed to must be lying by mislabeling massive numbers of vaccine deaths as covid deaths. You can download the data I used from here, if you want to check these calculations. So, why is he telling people that the vaccine kills 150,000 people? Horrific high levels in hospitals, airplanes, radio and tv studios, highways and other major roads are reading much higher now than a year ago. If the vaccine kills people, it doesnt matter if you take it on an island or a continent. If the vaccines are toxic, what is Kirschs solution to the pandemic? Steve Kirsch went on those websites and I think he emailed everyone who was open to alternative treatments.". Teenage suicide normally goes up during the school year and down during summer vacation. Media coverage of Kirschs descent into anti-vaccine rhetoric portrays an iconoclastic man who shouts at reporters and sends them emails in all caps. If Steve keeps up the way hes going, people will only remember the tantrum he threw after not winning: Steve Kirsch read this post and wrote a response. Its eye opening. But these very small amounts make their way to the liver, where they get chewed up. Fluvoxamine is the poster child of the COVID-19 Early Treatment Fund (CETF). In the middle of this article, I present an argument that should win one of Steves prizes. Mainly because friends and family had suffered. Steve embarked on a world saving quest in March 2020, to identify cheap, generic drugs that would fight covid: By March 2020, hed settled on the idea of searching for covid treatments in the pre-existing pharmacopeia. For his theory to be true, those 9 (mostly island) countries Ive pointed to must be lying and hiding their vaccine deaths. Hed end up the target for the conspiracy theories, not the source. So the deaths would happen soon after any country starts rolling out the vaccines. "Fluvoxamine is a highly effective anti-inflammatory treatment option which can dramatically lower hospitalization and fatality rates as well as lowering the risk of long-haul COVID and organ damage. Kirsch, whose net worth totals about $230 million, was diagnosed with waldenstrom's macroglobulinemia in the past and has funded research for that rare blood cancer through other philanthropic efforts. Data does not show Covid-19 vaccines are linked to more heart attacks. But the vaccine is supposed to be safe. Heres a graph of heart disease deaths in the US by week: The heart disease deaths spike at the same time as covid deaths spike, in spring 2020 and then again in winter. Steve would ignore any data I brought, change the subject a lot, and no one would learn anything from watching. In early 2021, Steven Kirsch, computing entrepreneur, medical philanthropist and vaccine skeptic, made this claim: "This vaccine seeks out your daughter's ovaries and instructs the cells in the ovaries to turn out a very toxic spike protein. Its an advice that we have for other diseases and for other viruses. The. The standard term for this debate tactic is gish gallop, its a trick where you just throw out so much bullshit that your opponent doesnt have the time to respond to it all. Because the CDC isnt telling doctors to recommend it. For some men, the ultimate status game is saving the world. Copyright HT Digital Streams Ltd. All rights reserved. Their justification is certainly worth debating. Our bodies do not make the coronavirus; they simply make the spike protein, and that protein becomes stuck inside the membrane of the cell that makes it. at the time of this writing, troponin levels were measured on 777 hospital employees who received a booster injection after having received two shots previously. The PR (a measure of heart function) used to be in the range of .12 to .2. Steve Kirsch Executive Director of the COVID-19 Early TreatmentFund stk@treatearly.org August 29, 2021 I am the founder of the COVID-19 Early Treatment Fund(www.treatearly.org). April 8, 2021. But it was on The Dark Horse Podcast, a show that has devolved into soft-spoken conspiracy mongering, that Kirsch, in conversation with Dr. Robert Malone, put his finger on why he thought the COVID-19 vaccines were so harmful. . Steve KirschPhoto: The COVID-19 Early Treatment Fund. Steve originally claimed that there were 25,000 vaccine deaths, and they were hidden in the CDCs unclassified deaths category (R00-R99 deaths). Then Crawford makes the assumption that the CFR went up because vaccine deaths got smuggled in to the covid death numbers, while cases stayed the same. First, lets ask: what do people do when they get so rich that they dont need more money? But its also a status game. They did it hoping nobody would notice. and just read the first chapter. Europe would have to be mislabeling vaccine deaths as covid deaths, as well, so its more like 40 countries in on the plot. The study included 113 workers at a California racetrack who tested positive for COVID-19 and were offered fluvoxamine. All the sudden deaths started post-vaccine. Were just identifying where the best work is to fund, looking for the best opportunities that can make the difference on lowering the hospitalization rates and lowering the fatality rates. On page 43 of his document, Steve says: the death rate is not going to be proportional to doses. A systematic review of published cases of shingles following (though not necessarily caused by) COVID vaccination identified 54 cases. He built a search engine, but it wasnt Google. In 2020, about 500,000 more people died in the US than in an average year. There is also a risk for QTc prolongation and rare but potentially deadly serotonin syndrome. No one should be promoting drug treatments for COVID until there is rigorous clinical trial evidence of their effectiveness. The changes were made on October 24, 2022 to the, For more information about the change, see, Think Im kidding about how they game the trials? Theres a clearer signal but its still pretty noisy: To double check, I pulled up the same same graph on OurWorldInData, they use a slightly different time lag between cases and deaths (10 days instead of 18), but its about the same shape as mine. Uh oh. QAnon wasnt just crazy because it theorized that Trump was fighting a global cabal of wealthy elites that terrorize children and drink their blood. However, the study relied upon patient self-report and self-measurement of symptoms. Youd have to look carefully to prove it. And, as with all of the current papers downplaying the significance of any vaccine side effect, however significant, The vaccine creates far more injury to the heart than COVID (, per this large-scale Israeli study of 196,992, I know from a study of 177 people in Puerto Rico (97% of whom were vaccinated) ages 8 to 84, that, There was a study done on pilots. His openness and creativity paid off when, to Steves surprise and delight, one such treatment worked. There is no prize. This would all be the greatest data conspiracy the world has ever seen, with at least 40 countries manipulating their hospital records, covid data, newspaper obituaries, and more to hide the evidence. STEVE KIRSCH (GUEST): They told -- the agencies, the FDA, the CDC, the NIH said that these vaccines were safe and effective. Maybe a lot of stuff. Another is to identify an asteroid that is going to hit the planet.. Like those who champion ivermectin, Kirsch argues that time is of the essence in the pandemic, and patients shouldn't have to wait until a phase III trial proves whether fluvoxamine works or not. I have to get one every six months. And to spend more on drug trials to prove which drugs work. What would the troponin levels have been at one day post-injection? The government message is not as interesting to many people. Crawford pretends hes shown that the vaccine is deadly. Scientists and clinicians are studying a host of drugs and therapeutics to create a new line of defence against the virus but clinical trials are yet to lead to conclusive evidence on any of these. CFR can go up and down for a few reasons. Kirsch told MedPage Today that his efforts are purely humanitarian -- almost no one was supporting this kind of research, so he stepped up to the plate. Not just a few pilots. In the next 3 months, while the elderly are being vaccinated, excess deaths were at 7.8%. Please consider making a donation on their website. All physician phone calls or video visits cost $115, cash only. In other words, the 29% rate of injury was a lower bound of injury. Think Im kidding about how they game the trials? To be thorough, lets consider Steves other argument: vaccine deaths have been hidden by calling them covid deaths. A central lesson we scientists learn in university is that science is complicated. Entries for each day are listed alphabetically by surname. Like investors, you dont want to invest in just one stock, says Kirsch. The post was exaggerated, later trials showed the drug was good but nowhere near 100% effective. It was just one row: Here are what it looks like as of Oct 24, 2022 (click the image to see the context): So its now two rows, one for less than 300 ms (it used to be 200 ms), and a second row to handle 300 ms or more. It turns out that most of Steves million dollar offers are actually bullshit. FALSE: Steve Kirsch, the FDA advisor, said that Covid-19 vaccines killed 150,000 Americans. Suicides actually went down in 2020. Here are 3 of them. In his three-minute presentation, Kirsch based his claim that heart attacks occur 71 times more often following COVID-19 . At the beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic, Steve Kirsch created the COVID-19 Early Treatment Fund (CETF) to finance trials of off-patent drugs in an attempt to find a potent treatment that had been staring us in the face. Steve Kirsch is looking for an explanation for 171,000 excess deaths. @hjametx made some graphs to show this clearly: Hjametx graphed this for 100 countries. He points to two blog posts by Mathew Crawford. Hes started several successful tech companies. In 2020, teenage suicide went down when we pulled kids out of school for covid. None of them were hospitalised versus 12.5% of the patients who chose not to. According to its founder, serial tech entrepreneur Steve Kirsch, CETF was started in April 2020 in order to fund drug repurposing research to find the fastest and most cost-effective early outpatient treatments for COVID-19. As I learn more, I will refine the estimate. But his estimate of the number of vaccine deaths in America is very far from the truth, so I would suggest you be very cautious in believing any other claims he makes. the shoulder muscle) comes from a study of 13 Moderna-vaccinated people that reported extremely low levels of it in the blood of 11 of them using ultralow detection technology. Opens in a new tab or window, Visit us on Instagram. The timing. When you have enough money, the next thing to acquire is status, to have people tell you youre important. Some countries were hit hard by covid, others made it through the pandemic with no excess deaths: We can look for a sign of vaccine deaths in places without covid deaths. The FDA doesnt approve drugs because theyre popular on social media. Safer and more effective than COVID vaccines! Some countries had few covid deaths. There are two ways Ive discovered that I may be able to save the world, he told an IEEE Spectrum reporter in 2000. Another found 91. Both concluded that, while it was possible the vaccine had somehow awakened the varicella-zoster virus in these people, this cause-and-effect link could not be established. I didn't have to get an EKG this time, but I do have to once a year (everyone 45 and over, I think). Does COVID-19 Mess with the Immune System? More likely, hes a grifter, pandering to a gullible audience. Gavin Newsom, left, receives a Moderna COVID-19 vaccine booster shot from California Health and Human Services Secretary Dr. Mark Ghaly at Asian Health Services in Oakland,. If the vaccines were as deadly as Steve thinks, youd expect a big 20% spike in excess mortality, while they were rolled out: There is no sign of a 20% increase. But while this effort was praiseworthy, Kirschs predilection for oversimplifying and exaggerating led him to mislead. Mouse Systems is not a household word, he told the journalist. nose bleeds, anal leakages, and the unbelievable swelling of the male reproductive apparatus, one in three people in the US will develop shingles, making unsupported claims during the pandemic, freeze the spike protein in the shape it has before unlocking the door to our cells, that protein becomes stuck inside the membrane of the cell that makes it, all 12 members of the scientific advisory board of his COVID-19 company to resign, declined a request for its emergency use authorization, what Steve Kirsch did back in December 2020, Kirsch pre-emptively accuses Obama and his friends, shouts at reporters and sends them emails in all caps, One of Last Centurys Most Influential Social Science Studies Is Pretty Bad. Get yourself a copy of Turtles All the Way Down and just read the first chapter.